Sponsored

Tesla Model Y. Rivian One Pedal Driving wins - hands down.

Dark-Fx

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Threads
148
Messages
13,592
Reaction score
27,464
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
R1T, R1S, Livewire One, Sierra EV, R1S
Occupation
Engineering
Clubs
 
Recently had a Chevy Silverado EV rental and the regen there is a disaster at best. Seems like it didn't account for speed, so at low speed it was too harsh and at high speed it was never enough.
The level is adjustable. I keep mine on High, it's generally enough to stop even at yellow lights without hitting the brakes. I'm guessing there's a chance the lower settings have an energy limitation, which is why it felt inconsistent. It requires taking a lot more energy to slow at high speeds vs low ones. Even towing a trailer I rarely have to hit the brake pedal.
Sponsored

 
OP
OP
Rade

Rade

Well-Known Member
First Name
Rade
Joined
Sep 19, 2024
Threads
36
Messages
609
Reaction score
778
Location
US - Rhode Island
Website
radmorningcoffee.blogspot.com
Vehicles
2025 Rivian R1T - Large. Delivered on November 23, 2024.
Occupation
Retired
Weaker OPD makes it easier to drive smoother if someone doesn't have great throttle control. I wish the Rivian had weaker OPD when my wife is driving! 😬
That's funny! When we sold our 2015 Nissan Rogue, the couple who bought it took it for test drive; it was going to be the wife's new car. They sat up front, I rode in the back seat. The car had that "lane departure warning" BEEP BEEP BEEP when the car would drift out of the lane. She was like "WHAT THE HELL IS THAT!", I calmly responded "That's the Rogue telling you that you are drifting out of your lane". The husband snorted, stifling his laughter, then told her, "...I guess you can deactivate that", then shot me a that glance.
 

madhat

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 27, 2024
Threads
10
Messages
334
Reaction score
380
Location
Arizona
Vehicles
22 R1T
Are you all sure you're apples to apples comparing? Is the brake assist option on where the Rivian will automatically use the friction brakes too if regen gets too potent?
Brake assist doesn't step in when regen is too potent. It steps in when regen is reduced to help maintain the same level of slow down regardless of how much regen can be utilized.

Me when regen isn't on high:
Rivian R1T R1S Tesla Model Y. Rivian One Pedal Driving wins - hands down. AE86-fifth-stag
 

loubendor

Member
First Name
Louis
Joined
Sep 19, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
21
Reaction score
10
Location
Bend, OR
Vehicles
2025 R1S
Occupation
retired
My perspective from owning a 2023 Model Y LR, (traded it for 2025 R1S). The older Y had stronger regen braking than the Rivian, I had to bump the Rivian’s regen to the higher setting to get the same feel as the 2023 Y. I’ve read that the programmable regen function has been removed from the newer Y’s, and from what I’m reading, the newer Y’s regen is weaker.
 

bigsky

Banned
Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Threads
12
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
740
Location
MUM
Vehicles
MUM
Just a note - I have SO gotten used to the One Pedal Driving (OPD) in my R1T; LOVE IT! I think, other than to tap the brakes to deactivate the cruise control or driver assist functions on occasion, I've used the actual brake pedal perhaps 5 times this YEAR. OPD Brings my 8,500 pound truck to a resounding stop and holds it there.

My husband just entered into a lease on a Tesla Model Y. The OPD is... weak... at best. The only time the vehicle stops (in what we perceive as a normal stopping distance to whatever is in front) is when FSD is engaged. Otherwise, under manual control, we have to use the brakes for the last 3 yards or so to get to a full stop. The HOLD function also tends to... not. Often the car begins creeping forward. It's... disconcerting. The vehicle is set for maximum OPD response, but... not that great.

Yeah, Rivian!
Undriven for a year, took out my glorious Tesla Model Y Performance for a spin today. If Rivian's regen implementation is the yardstick, regen braking on my beloved MYP is just as strong and excellent as, if not better than Rivian's. Perhaps regen has changed in Tesla later models.

Regen on my equally great Model S Raven, definitely not as strong; nonetheless, it is still quite good.

As for OPD, not sure what the deal is with your Tesla. OPD on either of my outstanding Teslas still shows that Tesla wrote the book (and it did, actually) on OPD. And just about everything else EV for that matter.
 

Sponsored

bigsky

Banned
Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2024
Threads
12
Messages
1,098
Reaction score
740
Location
MUM
Vehicles
MUM
Drive, own a Tesla, and perhaps you have. Having started my EV life with Teslas and driven them plenty for years, one needs not have a Ph.D in EV science to quickly notice that Rivian is inferior to Teslas, especially in software integration.

Don't get me wrong, Rivians are good, too, but owning both Teslas and now a Rivian, Rivian clearly comes up short always, e.g., ADAS, dumb Rivian MFA, half-smart Homelink, breakdowns, body corrosion, etc.
 

Donald Stanfield

Well-Known Member
First Name
Donald
Joined
Jul 31, 2022
Threads
59
Messages
8,316
Reaction score
16,663
Location
USA
Vehicles
2025 R1S Tri Ascend, 2024 i4 M50
Occupation
Stuff and things
Drive, own a Tesla, and perhaps you have. Having started my EV life with Teslas and driven them plenty for years, one needs not have a Ph.D in EV science to quickly notice that Rivian is inferior to Teslas, especially in software integration.

Don't get me wrong, Rivians are good, too, but owning both Teslas and now a Rivian, Rivian clearly comes up short always, e.g., ADAS, dumb Rivian MFA, half-smart Homelink, breakdowns, body corrosion, etc.
Laughs in overhead camera view.
 

Dark-Fx

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Threads
148
Messages
13,592
Reaction score
27,464
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
R1T, R1S, Livewire One, Sierra EV, R1S
Occupation
Engineering
Clubs
 
Drive, own a Tesla, and perhaps you have. Having started my EV life with Teslas and driven them plenty for years, one needs not have a Ph.D in EV science to quickly notice that Rivian is inferior to Teslas, especially in software integration.

Don't get me wrong, Rivians are good, too, but owning both Teslas and now a Rivian, Rivian clearly comes up short always, e.g., ADAS, dumb Rivian MFA, half-smart Homelink, breakdowns, body corrosion, etc.
Rivian comes up so short your Model Y sat undriven for a year.
 

KootenayEV

Well-Known Member
First Name
Andrew
Joined
Sep 22, 2021
Threads
28
Messages
614
Reaction score
589
Location
Nelson, BC
Vehicles
R1T, Tesla Model 3
Occupation
Environmental Engineer
Drive, own a Tesla, and perhaps you have. Having started my EV life with Teslas and driven them plenty for years, one needs not have a Ph.D in EV science to quickly notice that Rivian is inferior to Teslas, especially in software integration.

Don't get me wrong, Rivians are good, too, but owning both Teslas and now a Rivian, Rivian clearly comes up short always, e.g., ADAS, dumb Rivian MFA, half-smart Homelink, breakdowns, body corrosion, etc.
I'll counter your anecdote with my own, my 2018 Model 3 SUCKS in so many ways (including UI [excepting texting!]) compared to my R1T, particularly in the body corrosion department - this thing looks worse at 7 years old than my 15 year old Subaru Loyale when I was in my 20's.
 

sunydrm

Banned
Well-Known Member
First Name
Suraj
Joined
Nov 27, 2025
Threads
0
Messages
116
Reaction score
42
Location
Atlanta, GA
Vehicles
Rivian R1S Gen 2, Model Y
I have both and the answer is that if you have no blended braking then max regen is the theoretical most efficient way to drive. Old tesla models have strong regen because they do not have blended braking.

New model Y has blended braking which negates any advantage strong regen has. Strong OPD is less efficient in practice because it increases the likelyhood that you accidentally regen (jerky driving) which is inefficient.

That's why many rivian users report better efficiency with low regen. Because actually coasting and not accidentally using regen is better.

Tesla tuned model Y in a way you can still OPD while making it easier to coast, which is the most efficient way to drive.
Sponsored

 
Last edited:
 








Top