Sponsored

Quad motor vs locking diff

HaveBlue

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
1,131
Reaction score
805
Location
91107
Vehicles
R1S DMP Max, Lifted GX470, APR Audi A7, BMW 325Ci
Clubs
 
Electronic traction control has been around for at least 20 years on 4Wheel drives. It is still no better than a limited slip differential. Doesn't matter if the vehicle is diesel powered or electric. You can muscle your way through obstacles with it but inevitably you will break something. Beam axles cantilever weight to the opposite side unlike IFS/IRS but in the end a locking diff always takes you further off road.
I've owned solid axle open diff vehicles and they go amazing places. I've also owned locked trucks with lockers front and rear. They are beasts and Kyle's video would qualify as the road that leads to the trail for them; not the actual trail.
On occasion I've shifted into 4Lo on my current vehicle but forgotten to lock the transfer case center leaving it in all wheel drive low range with the traction control struggling like crazy; similar to this video. With it locked it behaves better of course but locking the rear axle changes the whole game immediately. Those who aren't Web Wheelers just understand this.
Unfortunately, Kyle was actually driving in the worst possible way for traction control to function. Letting off the throttle right when it started moving or even worse stepping on the brakes. Traction control designed for off road doesn't work at zero wheel rpm. On a gas powered rig, the best is to just maintain 1500 engine rpm steady through the obstacle. Subconsciously he realized he was going to break something (bumper, undercarriage, etc) using the traction control.
Sponsored

 

HarrySiii

Member
First Name
Harry
Joined
Mar 9, 2022
Threads
1
Messages
17
Reaction score
5
Location
New Hampshire, USA
Vehicles
2021 Ford Mustang Mach-E GTPE; 2018 Chrysler Pac.
Forgot to say.....you do realize that a limited slip diff in no way behaves like a locked diff, right? If you're truly worried about sliding off the cliff of death, you most definitely would want limited slip over locked for sure.
Edit: hum, actually that is rolling resistance, not rolling friction. Actually even though they are cross referenced in that link, they are completely different concepts.

I am quite sure some of you can explain this better than I can, so feel free to chime in but here goes:

Rolling Friction:
Although I am sure there is a more appropriate scientific term for it, we enthusiast types use this term to refer to the lateral resistance a rolling wheel retains as long as it is moving.

A static wheel has static friction, which is greater than sliding friction.

A freely rolling wheel maintains it's "lateral static coefficient" even when it is rolling; up until the friction is broken.

Once broken, the wheel will move in whatever direction forces act upon it, regardless of which direction it happens to be turning.

This is why a braking car on ice is out of control until the driver lets up on the brakes and lets at least 2 of the wheels spin with no resistance what-so-ever. If you can get at least a front & rear wheel "connected" and spinning again in this way, you will regain as much lateral control as the surface will allow. The other two can continue trying to slow (or accelerate) the vehicle while the "anchor" wheels maintain lateral control (i.e. keep you from sliding over the edge).

How did I do, is that close?

This is slick surface driving 101. NO! You do NOT want to use any more brake than you absolutely have to. NO!! You do NOT want your diff in any kind of locked or LS condition! You MUST have your diffs open, to allow complete free-wheeling of the wheels with the most traction to keep your vehicle from spinning out, moving sideways or falling off the trail. If you cannot gain enough traction with your other 2 wheels, you will be looking for other options (winch), but unless you are that nuub that just bought a Jeep and wanted to tag along with the big boys, you do NOT lock your diffs; or over the side you go.

I know I did not do as well at explaining this as some of you may be able to do, but I have come to see that there are those not aware of how this works.
Ok, so I finally made it to the end...for now...page 21, after 2 or 3 days of reading. Mostly great info and conversation.

I have a couple of questions on the two quotes above which sound contradictory to other quotes in this thread about locked versus open, etc.

Are you saying (RIP) that in your case you'd want an OPEN diff? I though through the rest of this you were saying that you'd only trust a LOCKED diff in your example. The example being off-camber snowy/slippery surface. I would think a LOCKED diff would also cause you to slide off the cliff in the case that all 4 wheels were slipping underneath (obviously not if any one wheel had traction). Otherwise, a limited-slip would be best, correct?


In that case, what others are saying about a speed-applied 4 wheel setup could also work, because it can add speed only keeping speed with the wheel with the most traction (PROACTIVE). Of course, if at any time this acts in a REACTIVE fashion, it would be best to have only the crawling mode implement this at extremely low speeds in low traction situations. (again, as others have said, product managers and engineering need to decide this is a high enough priority to code and implement)

Alternatively, if there were enough room in the packaging, they could add E-locking diffs between the two motors (and maybe even a driveshaft front-rear) to satisfy this use-case scenario. That would severely change design and cargo capacities of the vehicle, which they wouldn't do for the masses, but maybe another off-model once they truly make it "big" (enough).

Edit: Additionally, you'd want the latter type of setup at least electronically connected the same-axle motors to achieve more power output to a single wheel.
 

HaveBlue

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
1,131
Reaction score
805
Location
91107
Vehicles
R1S DMP Max, Lifted GX470, APR Audi A7, BMW 325Ci
Clubs
 
The patents showed that locking diffs were possible in the housings. They elected not to implement them. An after market carrier will be the only other solution for dual motor.
 
OP
OP
R.I.P.

R.I.P.

Well-Known Member
First Name
Sean
Joined
Jan 2, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
1,495
Location
San Carlos, Mexico
Vehicles
Tesla Y, Cadillac ELR, Rivian R1T, Jeep TJ, F250
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
"Are you saying (RIP) that in your case you'd want an OPEN diff?"

Yes. The power of an open diff is the biggest thing the quad motor design is missing, and the reason it is incapable of safeguarding rolling friction.
 

MountainBikeDude

Well-Known Member
First Name
Adam
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Threads
40
Messages
1,878
Reaction score
3,845
Location
Vancouver
Vehicles
2023 El Cap Quad Motor R1T (Selling the Xterra)
Clubs
 
It's official... @R.I.P. is actually ChatGPT in disguise!

Rivian R1T R1S Quad motor vs locking diff Screenshot 2023-02-08 at 16-00-45 ChatGPT
 

Sponsored

OP
OP
R.I.P.

R.I.P.

Well-Known Member
First Name
Sean
Joined
Jan 2, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
1,495
Location
San Carlos, Mexico
Vehicles
Tesla Y, Cadillac ELR, Rivian R1T, Jeep TJ, F250
Occupation
Electrical Engineer

MountainBikeDude

Well-Known Member
First Name
Adam
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Threads
40
Messages
1,878
Reaction score
3,845
Location
Vancouver
Vehicles
2023 El Cap Quad Motor R1T (Selling the Xterra)
Clubs
 
Sorry, remember, I am an old Oregon Longhair... So not as up on this online stuff as most... What is "Chat GPT?"
No worries man, check out the link. Also this YouTube channel does great work
 

Acon

Active Member
First Name
Albert
Joined
Nov 18, 2020
Threads
2
Messages
44
Reaction score
48
Location
New York
Vehicles
F150
Can someone just post a summary so I don't have to go through 21 pages of posts...
 

MountainBikeDude

Well-Known Member
First Name
Adam
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Threads
40
Messages
1,878
Reaction score
3,845
Location
Vancouver
Vehicles
2023 El Cap Quad Motor R1T (Selling the Xterra)
Clubs
 
Can someone just post a summary so I don't have to go through 21 pages of posts...
No! Haha

One must read the previous 20 pages to understand the struggles in getting to 21.
 
OP
OP
R.I.P.

R.I.P.

Well-Known Member
First Name
Sean
Joined
Jan 2, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
1,495
Location
San Carlos, Mexico
Vehicles
Tesla Y, Cadillac ELR, Rivian R1T, Jeep TJ, F250
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
Can someone just post a summary so I don't have to go through 21 pages of posts...
The chat GDP quote above does a decent job of summary. It is not as specific as the testing I did, but definitely gives you the idea.
 

Sponsored

Zybane

Banned
Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2021
Threads
9
Messages
294
Reaction score
432
Location
Crestone Colorado
Vehicles
Ford Raptor 37
Occupation
Military Pilot
I think this video shows the issues with Rivian's quad motor setup well at the 7 minute mark:




Rivian struggling with a little bit of loose rocks on an almost level surface. Notice the right rear wheel/tire accelerating and decelerating at rapid speeds, tossing rocks out, tons of shock loads on that driveline (bad).

An ICE off-road vehicle in low range with a locked rear differential would have literally slowly idled over that without touching any pedals.
 
OP
OP
R.I.P.

R.I.P.

Well-Known Member
First Name
Sean
Joined
Jan 2, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
1,495
Location
San Carlos, Mexico
Vehicles
Tesla Y, Cadillac ELR, Rivian R1T, Jeep TJ, F250
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
I think this video shows the issues with Rivian's quad motor setup well at the 7 minute mark:




Rivian struggling with a little bit of loose rocks on an almost level surface. Notice the right rear wheel/tire accelerating and decelerating at rapid speeds, tossing rocks out, tons of shock loads on that driveline (bad).

An ICE off-road vehicle in low range with a locked rear differential would have literally slowly idled over that without touching any pedals.
Yup. They do fine on some stuff, but fail shockingly (at least to me) in seemingly very benign areas.
 

MountainBikeDude

Well-Known Member
First Name
Adam
Joined
Jun 20, 2019
Threads
40
Messages
1,878
Reaction score
3,845
Location
Vancouver
Vehicles
2023 El Cap Quad Motor R1T (Selling the Xterra)
Clubs
 
I think this video shows the issues with Rivian's quad motor setup well at the 7 minute mark:




Rivian struggling with a little bit of loose rocks on an almost level surface. Notice the right rear wheel/tire accelerating and decelerating at rapid speeds, tossing rocks out, tons of shock loads on that driveline (bad).

An ICE off-road vehicle in low range with a locked rear differential would have literally slowly idled over that without touching any pedals.
Sure, but you also would have been going near dead straight or dragging wheels on any sort of cornering manouver, putting similar "bad" loads on the driveline despite the loose surface.

Driving in that same outing as the video in a conventional setup, you would have likely been in 4 high, open diffs, until you got stuck, then locked the axel and tried again.

My current vehicle would have done something similar to the Rivian, it just wouldn't have tossed the rocks as far becuase my vehicle is gutless. As a result, I don't think this is much of gotcha or benign failure of the system over the terrain.
 

rivmok

Active Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
36
Reaction score
28
Location
MD
Vehicles
Audi RS3, Jeep Wrangler
Clubs
 
R1T did better than the Jeep Gladiator Mojave w/rear locker in this video:

 
OP
OP
R.I.P.

R.I.P.

Well-Known Member
First Name
Sean
Joined
Jan 2, 2023
Threads
11
Messages
1,129
Reaction score
1,495
Location
San Carlos, Mexico
Vehicles
Tesla Y, Cadillac ELR, Rivian R1T, Jeep TJ, F250
Occupation
Electrical Engineer
R1T did better than the Jeep Gladiator Mojave w/rear locker in this video:

When the Rivian can get its power to the ground, it does well. This is one of those scenarios where it shines.

Where the quad motor struggles is low traction conditions where it can't get that power to the ground.

Another really good example of what we're talking about here.
😎
Sponsored

 
 




Top