Ostrichsak
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2022
- Threads
- 3
- Messages
- 81
- Reaction score
- 93
- Location
- Colorado, USA
- Vehicles
- Lots of Teslas, Future: R2
So if you put the word "fact" in quotes like that does that make it not really a fact? If so, these statements seem accurate to me. Like saying that the NY Jets are a "good" football team.The "fact" is that there is no concrete definition of SUV, but any source you look at will list higher ground clearance and off-road capability as two of the distinguishing features. That's not a MY.
And the "fact" is that true SUVs have gradually moved more towards sedans over the years, while sedans have moved towards crossovers/SUVs.
MY is a passenger carrier. Nothing wrong with that, but it's just not a SUV.
Let me suggest that YOU are the one with the weird view that the MY is a SUV and can be compared to an old-school Wagoneer or Bronco or Scout or 4Runner.
The "dumbing-down" of the SUV over the years is one of the main reasons I found the R1 so attractive.
Listen, you can argue all you want (and I'm sure you will) about how much better the R2 is than the Model Y. That's largely opinion and others may challenge that opinion. That's fine. I'm not debating that.
Saying that these two vehicles aren't both midsize SUVs is factual incorrect. The word class used in the automotive segment has a very specific meaning and by that meaning they're in the same class.
Any magazine, insurance company or online car sales website will list them BOTH as SUVs. Midsize SUV if they want to get really specific and narrow things down. Whether we like it or not, a Dodge Journey is classified as an SUV even though we all know it's a minivan. Just like when the Honda Ridgeline came out it was listed as a pick-up truck. We all know it wasn't capable of doing pick-up truck things since it was a minivan w/a pick-up truck bed but that didn't change the classification.
These stupid made up classes like "Adventure This" and "Outdoor That" are simply marketing terms and mean nothing otherwise. Both the Model Y and the R2 are SUVs no matter how loudly you shout that they aren't. People are interested in one will directly compare it to the other and determine which best meets their individual needs. That's how things work in the real world where debate about opinions isn't the rule of law. Thankfully.
No, you.Check yourself.
Sponsored