jdhiker23
Active Member
We keep talking about regen and strength of regen in this thread, but I think the different preferences people are describing are actually better addressed by the pedal response (how movement of the "gas" pedal translates to increased power or regeneration). I have to assume that the R1 pedal response will not be linear in the normal drive mode (with the power these vehicles can deliver, a linear pedal response would likely give you a far more jerky response than you want for normal driving). So if we already have a non-linear pedal response curve in the software, it is easy to dial in a wide enough "dead band" around the zero regeneration spot that you can back off on the pedal to a middle point and coast. With a wide dead band, you won't get a surging feel or unwanted acceleration/deceleration from minor pedal movement in this part of the curve (what @flabyboy wants to avoid with kids that get carsick easily and when driving on ice), but if you back off the pedal even further you can get as much regeneration as you want. IMHO, the one key point where regen strength matters more than pedal response curve is when you take your foot completely off the pedal. I get the desire to take your foot off the pedal from time to time on long drives, which is not an option with one pedal driving without cruise control. Before getting my current vehicle with adaptive cruise control, I would have been in the camp of demanding an option for this use case, but now I'm so used to seamlessly switching on and off adaptive cruise control in these scenarios that I no longer have a desire for this.
Finally, one more point on the pedal response curve and why I think it is more important to the driving experience than strength of regen. Since everything is electronically controlled, you can make the wide dead band in pedal response at the point where the vehicle is coasting (zero power in or out from the motors) or you can make it at the zero acceleration point (zero change in speed). A zero acceleration point would work like cruise control in that it would increase power going uphill and regen going downhill such that you would keep the same speed if you don't change the pedal position. I doubt Rivian would implement this as the default response, since it would feel very un-intuitive coming from an ICE vehicle, but it's another option and might be useful for specialized driving modes like rock crawling where you want a consistent (very low) speed even though the power delivery will be changing dramatically to achieve this as the wheels encounter obstacles.
Finally, one more point on the pedal response curve and why I think it is more important to the driving experience than strength of regen. Since everything is electronically controlled, you can make the wide dead band in pedal response at the point where the vehicle is coasting (zero power in or out from the motors) or you can make it at the zero acceleration point (zero change in speed). A zero acceleration point would work like cruise control in that it would increase power going uphill and regen going downhill such that you would keep the same speed if you don't change the pedal position. I doubt Rivian would implement this as the default response, since it would feel very un-intuitive coming from an ICE vehicle, but it's another option and might be useful for specialized driving modes like rock crawling where you want a consistent (very low) speed even though the power delivery will be changing dramatically to achieve this as the wheels encounter obstacles.
Sponsored