Sponsored

Musk's twitter problem a boon for Rivian sales? [***NO POLITICS***]

PeterSK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Peter
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
190
Reaction score
204
Location
Cambridge, MA
Vehicles
2023 FG/FE R1S, 2020 Model Y
Occupation
Retired / board director
Clubs
 
I'm new here, and my first stab at this touched (as neutrally as possible) on politics so was deleted. I'll try again with my observations on this question.

I read a respected TSLA analyst's comments the other day (can't remember who) which I agree with, who said that Musk's Twitter activity has three negative impacts on Tesla/TSLA: 1) Musk sold $4B of TSLA to help fund the acquisition, and there are concerns he will need to sell more; 2) He is distracted by Twitter at a time when Tesla needs attention to get Austin/Berlin fully ramped up and new plants launched, and delayed new products and software done, etc.; 3) Because of his strong personal association with Tesla, Musk's comments/actions on Twitter create a reputational impact on the Tesla brand.

I've owned Teslas and TSLA for about ten years, and observed over the decade that as Musk has gained fame, he's become more of a publicity-starved and often puerile jerk. This is particularly true in the last few years, as Tesla's success and Musk's incredible wealth materialized. He was no longer struggling with Model 3 production hell, so had time on his hands and started looking for other diversions like Twitter.

I run an annual fundraising Tesla raffle for a Boston-based climate nonprofit, Climate XChange. This year is our 7th year, and sales started out slow. We fixed some technical issues with Google Ads and our site index, but they were still slow. Then we got feedback that some past and potential ticket buyers are no longer excited about winning a Tesla, given Musk's recent behavior. So I looked at alternatives, and we made deposits and added the R1S and R1T as extra grand prize options for those not interested in a Tesla! My research brought me here, which reminds me of what Tesla Motors Club used to be in the old days, before the huge volumes of Models 3 and Y. I wound up put down a personal R1S deposit as well, to replace my aging 2016 X.

So my response to the original question is that Musk's Twitter antics are probably not a near-term boon for Rivian and other EVs' sales, at least because at the moment most are supply-constrained, but I think they will help Rivian and other EV brands establish themselves as viable alternatives to Tesla, perhaps earlier than might have happened otherwise.

That said, maybe this is all Musk playing 3-dimensional chess to drive Tesla's mission of auto industry transformation - he gets some of the original Tesla buyers to switch to and drive growth of other EV brands, while his new fans start buying Teslas!
I think my Musk 3-dimensional chess theory to sell Teslas to his new fans, while it may have been Elon's hope, is a fail...

Rivian R1T R1S Musk's twitter problem a boon for Rivian sales? [***NO POLITICS***] 1673368684483
Sponsored

 

Dark-Fx

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Threads
96
Messages
9,360
Reaction score
17,749
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
Polestar 2, R1T, R1S, Livewire One, Fisker Ocean
Occupation
Engineering
Clubs
 
I think my Musk 3-dimensional chess theory to sell Teslas to his new fans, while it may have been Elon's hope, is a fail...

1673368684483.png
Imagine being on catturds side of the aisle and acting like you give a shit about the environmental aspects of a vehicle just for the sake of being argumentative.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JPC

Inkedsphynx

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Threads
4
Messages
1,021
Reaction score
2,031
Location
Washington
Vehicles
'22 LE R1T, '21 CB500FA, '21 CMX1100A
I'd comment more thoroughly on this thread but it's basically impossible for me to separate Musk from politics at this point, and that's entirely his doing.

I'll just say this - in the very early years I was super excited about Tesla and very much wanted one. In the middle years I had already figured out Elon was not the messiah most think he is and I was way less excited but still willing to go for a Tesla, despite Elon. Now - you literally couldn't pay me to own a Tesla.

All three of these stances can be directly tied to Elon and only Elon.

I don't expect my opinions to be everyone's opinions, but I think there are enough of us with that opinion that Tesla will lose sales. At a minimum they've lost any potential future sale from me. So yes, Musk's behavior since acquiring Twitter, and on Twitter, are going to impact his sales and help his competitors.
 

Mathme

Well-Known Member
First Name
Matt
Joined
Jul 25, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
649
Reaction score
773
Location
Los Altos, CA
Vehicles
R1T: El Cap, OC, 20AT, Off road package
Occupation
High Tech
For a long time, Tesla was basically the only EV game in town. Noe, I think the largest problem with Tesla is the Model S is 10 years old, the X is about 8-9, while the 3 and Y are about 5 model years old. Additionally, there's the notorious build quality with Tesla. The Savior Cybertruck is vaporware at this point.

There are many newer EVs coming to market each day and when people have a choice, they will make choices.

Yes Tesla has a great charging network but with the fed $ going to EV charging, that Tesla supercharger network won't be a standout forever.
 

Bristlecone

Well-Known Member
First Name
Tom
Joined
Jan 5, 2022
Threads
17
Messages
99
Reaction score
50
Location
Colorado
Vehicles
Volvo XC40 Recharge, Toyota 4Runner
Occupation
Retired (newspaper reporter)
Clubs
 
I'd comment more thoroughly on this thread but it's basically impossible for me to separate Musk from politics at this point, and that's entirely his doing.

I'll just say this - in the very early years I was super excited about Tesla and very much wanted one. In the middle years I had already figured out Elon was not the messiah most think he is and I was way less excited but still willing to go for a Tesla, despite Elon. Now - you literally couldn't pay me to own a Tesla.

All three of these stances can be directly tied to Elon and only Elon.

I don't expect my opinions to be everyone's opinions, but I think there are enough of us with that opinion that Tesla will lose sales. At a minimum they've lost any potential future sale from me. So yes, Musk's behavior since acquiring Twitter, and on Twitter, are going to impact his sales and help his competitors.
Same.
 

Sponsored

Dark-Fx

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Threads
96
Messages
9,360
Reaction score
17,749
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
Polestar 2, R1T, R1S, Livewire One, Fisker Ocean
Occupation
Engineering
Clubs
 

Inkedsphynx

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Threads
4
Messages
1,021
Reaction score
2,031
Location
Washington
Vehicles
'22 LE R1T, '21 CB500FA, '21 CMX1100A
Time to compare your nostalgia to today's reality.

https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a15117388/2013-tesla-model-s-test-review/

My R1T is significantly better than Tesla's first mass-market product.
I've been dreaming of owning an electric vehicle since I was a kid, many many years ago. Tesla was the first realistic opportunity for me to make that a reality while also meeting my other personal needs and desires.

The R1T wasn't even a dream at the time when I was excited about the idea of owning a Tesla. At that time, it was the only thing of it's kind on the planet, similar to how the R1T was when I first got it. I'm not being nostalgic at all, I don't have positive feelings in retrospect for Tesla, but again, it was the first thing out there that would have potentially allowed me to realize a life-long dream. Of course I was excited about the idea.

If Tesla and Rivian were side-by-side out of the gate last year, I'd 100% have chosen Rivian over Tesla, but that's not really a realistic comparison. I'm also certainly not going to state that Tesla's initial quality was superior to Rivian's. Quite the opposite, in fact.
 

PeterSK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Peter
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
190
Reaction score
204
Location
Cambridge, MA
Vehicles
2023 FG/FE R1S, 2020 Model Y
Occupation
Retired / board director
Clubs
 
I'd comment more thoroughly on this thread but it's basically impossible for me to separate Musk from politics at this point, and that's entirely his doing.

I'll just say this - in the very early years I was super excited about Tesla and very much wanted one. In the middle years I had already figured out Elon was not the messiah most think he is and I was way less excited but still willing to go for a Tesla, despite Elon. Now - you literally couldn't pay me to own a Tesla.

All three of these stances can be directly tied to Elon and only Elon.

I don't expect my opinions to be everyone's opinions, but I think there are enough of us with that opinion that Tesla will lose sales. At a minimum they've lost any potential future sale from me. So yes, Musk's behavior since acquiring Twitter, and on Twitter, are going to impact his sales and help his competitors.

I agree. And clearly many others do, as witnessed by the dismal sales in our raffle this year. They've picked up somewhat since we added the Rivians, but we have sold about half the tickets we did at this time last year, and have just over six weeks to go... thanks, Elon.
 

PeterSK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Peter
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
190
Reaction score
204
Location
Cambridge, MA
Vehicles
2023 FG/FE R1S, 2020 Model Y
Occupation
Retired / board director
Clubs
 
Time to compare your nostalgia to today's reality.

https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a15117388/2013-tesla-model-s-test-review/

My R1T is significantly better than Tesla's first mass-market product.
True, but Rivian was able to stand on the shoulders of Tesla and others. A decade since the Model S introduction made for lots of learning. And Rivian intelligently borrowed much of the driver interface from Tesla (not the yoke and buttons, thankfully!), making it easier for drivers to transition from or switch back and forth between Tesla and Rivian. When my R1S is delivered I will trade in my 2016 Model X but will still have a Model Y that I will continue to drive frequently.
 

Dark-Fx

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Jul 15, 2020
Threads
96
Messages
9,360
Reaction score
17,749
Location
Michigan
Vehicles
Polestar 2, R1T, R1S, Livewire One, Fisker Ocean
Occupation
Engineering
Clubs
 
I'm also certainly not going to state that Tesla's initial quality was superior to Rivian's. Quite the opposite, in fact.
I got to see the Model S sheet metal before the vehicle was officially revealed. I briefly worked on the paint system while a coworker was out sick and people from Tesla were visiting our plant to sign off on the equipment. He warned me how bad those guys were to do work for. He was right about them and it soured me on Tesla (beyond that I couldn't afford one back then anyway). Tesla just had to do things their way and it caused a lot of issues for us. I don't think I really knew back then that it was likely a corporate culture expectation, but I certainly do now.
 

Sponsored

Inkedsphynx

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 27, 2021
Threads
4
Messages
1,021
Reaction score
2,031
Location
Washington
Vehicles
'22 LE R1T, '21 CB500FA, '21 CMX1100A
I got to see the Model S sheet metal before the vehicle was officially revealed. I briefly worked on the paint system while a coworker was out sick and people from Tesla were visiting our plant to sign off on the equipment. He warned me how bad those guys were to do work for. He was right about them and it soured me on Tesla (beyond that I couldn't afford one back then anyway). Tesla just had to do things their way and it caused a lot of issues for us. I don't think I really knew back then that it was likely a corporate culture expectation, but I certainly do now.
For me the barrier to entry was affordability as well. If not for that I'm sure I'd have bought one, but I wasn't quite at that stage of life yet back then. In retrospect I'm really glad the R1T is my first EV. It's everything I expected and more and I sincerely doubt I'd have been as happy with any other available EV prior to it, based on my lifestyle, needs, and ethos.
 

PeterSK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Peter
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
190
Reaction score
204
Location
Cambridge, MA
Vehicles
2023 FG/FE R1S, 2020 Model Y
Occupation
Retired / board director
Clubs
 
For me the barrier to entry was affordability as well. If not for that I'm sure I'd have bought one, but I wasn't quite at that stage of life yet back then. In retrospect I'm really glad the R1T is my first EV. It's everything I expected and more and I sincerely doubt I'd have been as happy with any other available EV prior to it, based on my lifestyle, needs, and ethos.
Because I could afford it, it felt like I should buy an early Model S - even though it cost twice what I’d ever spent on a car previously, there was only one supercharger location between Boston and NYC, my most frequent road trip, and none in other directions. It was pretty clear to me that if the Model S were a success that would drive other manufacturers to go electric. While waiting for my car I did more research and bought some TSLA, though of course I wish I’d bought more - and sold it all a year ago!

That article made me nostalgic for my S85 (VIN in the 6000s) that I sold in 2016 when I got an even earlier Model X (VIN in the 600s) because kids had outgrown those rear-facing seats. And s00n I’ll replace the X with an R1S!
 

PeterSK

Well-Known Member
First Name
Peter
Joined
Nov 22, 2022
Threads
5
Messages
190
Reaction score
204
Location
Cambridge, MA
Vehicles
2023 FG/FE R1S, 2020 Model Y
Occupation
Retired / board director
Clubs
 
 




Top